Prepaid maintenance plans let you pay for scheduled services upfront, but are they really worth it? While they may simplify car care, prepaid plans don’t always cover everything, and they might not be the right choice for every driver. 

Here’s our breakdown of what these plans offer and whether they’re a good investment for you. 

---

Key Takeaways:

• Prepaid maintenance plans can make routine car care easier and sometimes more affordable, but they don’t typically include major repairs. 
• Car maintenance plans can be worth it if you drive a lot or need frequent oil changes or tire rotations. 
• In California, prepaid maintenance plans don’t affect your rights under the Lemon Law.  

What Is a Prepaid Car Maintenance Plan?

A prepaid car maintenance plan is basically a way to pay in advance for a set of routine vehicle services. Instead of paying out of pocket every time you need an oil change or tire rotation, you purchase a plan up-front that covers these services for a certain period or mileage. Dealerships and manufacturers often offer these plans as a convenient way to keep up with scheduled maintenance.

What Does Prepaid Maintenance Cover?

Every plan is different, but most prepaid maintenance packages focus on routine care outlined in your owner’s manual. You can expect coverage for services such as oil and filter changes, tire rotations, and general inspections to catch small issues before they turn into major problems.  

Some plans may go a step further and include services like brake pad replacements or new wiper blades, although it varies by dealership. 

Does It Cover Major Repairs?

No, prepaid maintenance plans don’t usually include major repairs. So, if your engine or transmission fails, that would fall under a warranty or extended service contract, not your prepaid plan.

Maintenance Plan vs. Warranty

While it’s easy to confuse the two, maintenance plans and warranties serve different purposes. You can think of prepaid maintenance as prevention; it keeps your car in working order through regular checkups. Warranties, on the other hand, protect you when something goes wrong despite proper maintenance. 

If you’re trying to decide if a prepaid plan is worth it, make sure you also understand your warranty coverage so you’re not paying twice for overlapping services.

Are Prepaid Maintenance Plans Worth It?

Whether or not a prepaid plan is worth buying depends on your driving habits and how you prefer to handle car expenses. If you drive a lot and need frequent oil changes and tire rotations, it might be a smart investment. The more you use it, the more value you’ll get out of it. 

It can also make sense for people who like predictable costs or don’t want to think about individual service bills. But, on the other hand, if you don’t drive very often or prefer to go to independent mechanics for better rates, the plan might end up costing more than it saves. Another con is that some plans only allow you to go to specific dealerships, which could be inconvenient if you move or prefer a local mechanic.

Other Frequently Asked Questions

Can You Cancel a Prepaid Maintenance Plan?

Most prepaid maintenance plans can be canceled, although the exact terms depend on the provider. If you change your mind right after you purchase the plan, you may be able to cancel within a specific period and receive a partial refund for any unused services. 

If you’ve already used some of the plan, the refund is usually prorated. Some plans may also charge a small cancellation fee.

What Happens If You Don’t Use All the Services?

If you don’t use all the services in your prepaid plan, you generally won’t get a refund for what’s left. For example, if your plan includes four oil changes and you only use two before it expires, you’ll likely lose the remaining value, which is one of the most common drawbacks.

Will a Prepaid Maintenance Plan Affect My Lemon Law Rights?

In California, having a prepaid maintenance plan has no effect on your Lemon Law protections. The Lemon Law applies when an under-warranty vehicle has significant defects that affect its use, safety, or value, and those problems can’t be fixed after a reasonable number of attempts. 

Maintenance plans only deal with routine service, not with factory defects. If your car qualifies as a lemon, the manufacturer is still responsible for addressing the issue. Having a prepaid maintenance plan doesn’t change or limit your rights in any way. You’re still protected under state law if your vehicle meets the Lemon Law criteria.

Have Questions About California’s Lemon Laws? Contact Us 

If you have questions about your rights under California’s Lemon Law, our firm has decades of experience standing up for California consumers and helping them understand their options. 

Whether you’re dealing with warranty confusion or recurring issues with your 2020 or newer vehicle, contact us online or call 818-244-3905 today to schedule a free consultation with our lemon law attorneys! 

Schedule my consultation

---

✓ Content checked by the lemon law attorneys at Norman Taylor & Associates