Quality And The Lemon Automobile
Norman Taylor & Associates
September 30, 2013
“It costs a lot to build bad products.” Norman Augustine�”Augustine’s 12th Law”
In America we salute quantity and pay lip service to quality. When manufacturers want to brag, they cite numbers of units produced, tons of ore mined, miles of cable laid, or millions of books sold. People involved in high production get gold-plated plaques, vacations in Las Vegas and outrageous bonuses. Where is quality management while this is happening? Fighting with production supervisors to maintain standards, trying to get budget to buy inspection tools, trying to get people to attend manufacturing and process improvement classes. The quality supervisor buys quality award certificates from Office Depot and fills them in himself.
Quantity has high sociological value. Producing lots of anything shows you have the “right corporate stuff”. We give high production admiration and handsomely reward those who deliver the goods.
Quality is acknowledged as a good thing, but we expect to pay dearly for it, and management is secretly willing to sacrifice quality to get better production numbers. We sneered at German manufacturing and their devotion to quality. And why not, in a long war we proved decisively that quantity could defeat quality. We out-produced them at every turn and won a great victory. When a person or group succeeds in a great endeavor, that event can become a measuring stick for all similar future activities. It is, of course, poor reasoning at best. Yesterday’s solution is seldom appropriate for today’s problems.
In years gone by, if you were successful in life, made some money, you bought a quality German automobile. You told all your pals how well it was put together, how long it lasted. It isn’t true any more. J. D. Power and Associates rates Mercedes automobiles as a little below average compared to other automobiles. Something changed. Quality is what changed. Quantity: Hail to thee, yardstick of real success in America and the world.
What is quality? Go to your bookstore and check the section on quality. It’s big. A lot of smart people have had a lot to say about it. And still it plays second fiddle to quantity. It seems so simple. Here’s an absolute truism. It’s very expensive to build defective products. We ought to say this again. It’s very expensive to build defective products. We could also say, it’s very expensive to produce a lemon vehicle. But it’s not enough to say it. Those who are involved in the world of production have to learn it, absorb it; have it become as much a part of their lives as knowing how to drive their car.
“Like the frog that will sit in a pot of water and let itself be slowly boiled to death, we are very good at reacting to immediate danger to our survival, but we are very poor at recognizing gradual threats.” — Peter Senge
Downplaying the value of rigorous quality programs has gradual but inevitable effects. How long did it taken Mercedes to go from a premier automobile manufacturer to just average? Roughly ten years. It’s expensive to ignore or downplay quality. Figure 1 shows a few of the costs associated with manufacturing a defective automobile.
Figure 1. The Costs of Manufacturing a Lemon Vehicle
Here’s another verse on the theme of this article.
Defects are not free. Somebody makes them & gets paid for making them. – Anonymous
Figure 2. A modern Manufacturing Catch-22
Lest you think it is all bad, it isn’t. Some manufacturers make real efforts to create quality products and services. But there is a Catch-22 waiting in the weeds, and it is a tough one. As we stated in an earlier article, talking about the complexity of the modern automobile, what can one do when the average vehicle has 10,000 to 15,000 parts? The chances that something will go wrong, that lemon vehicles in large numbers will be produced, increases exponentially. But Lexus and Infinity seem to have solved the quality problem, so manufacturers are not really stuck in this Catch-22.
In the war between quality and the bottom line, the bottom line always wins out. Promotions aren’t passed out when people improve quality and sustain these improvements. The young executive fresh from Wharton or Harvard has a plan, and that plan is promotion. He or she has been taught shortsightedness in school and by our peculiar marketplace. There is no incentive to plan for quality on a long-term basis of years. But, there is every incentive to increase production and sales.
One of the results of this battle is more and more lemon vehicles on our highways. Until manufacturers become convinced that it’s cheaper to build quality vehicles than it is to build more vehicles, and hide the defects, the current situation is not likely to change. So far the accountants have the upper hand, just as they did in the 60’s when Ford Pintos were exploding all over the roads of America.