If you’ve just wrapped up a lemon law settlement, you might be wondering: are these settlements taxable in California? It’s a good question — and an important one — because taxes can make a big difference in your finances. Here’s what you need to know!

 

What Is the Lemon Law in California?

The California Lemon Law, also known as the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, is designed to protect consumers who purchase or lease vehicles that fail to meet quality or performance standards. It applies to new vehicles purchased or leased within the state.

 

What Makes a Car a Lemon?

A car might be considered a lemon if it meets these conditions:   

• The vehicle must still be under the manufacturer’s warranty. 
• The problem must significantly affect the car’s use, safety, or value. 
• The manufacturer or dealer has tried and failed to fix the issue multiple times. 
• The problem shows up within 18,000 miles or the first 18 months, whichever is first. 

If your vehicle qualifies, you could be entitled to a refund, replacement, or cash settlement. 

 

Types of Lemon Law Settlements

When you file a lemon law claim, there are a few settlement options you might come across:

Refunds and Buybacks

A buyback occurs when the manufacturer agrees to repurchase a defective vehicle; this option typically includes reimbursement for: 

• The original purchase price
• Sales tax
• Licensing fees
• Additional expenses related to the purchase

 

Replacement Vehicles

In some cases, the manufacturer may offer a replacement vehicle of equal or greater value; this option allows you to receive a new car at no extra cost. 

 

Cash Settlements

Cash settlements are another option where the manufacturer compensates you with a lump sum payment instead of a refund or replacement. However, these settlements tend to favor the manufacturer and may not fully cover your losses. 

 

Are Lemon Law Settlements Taxable in California?

So, are lemon law settlements taxable in California? It’s not always a clear-cut answer. Generally, the IRS and California’s tax authorities view most lemon law settlements as compensatory payments rather than taxable income.

Refunds and Buybacks

Refunds for the purchase price of your lemon car are usually not taxable since you’re just getting your money back. However, if you’ve previously claimed deductions related to the vehicle, such as business use or sales tax, the refund may be subject to taxation.

 

Replacement Vehicles

Swapping your lemon for a new car typically isn’t taxable. However, the difference could count as taxable income if the replacement vehicle is worth more.

 

Cash Settlements

Cash settlements can complicate matters. While the money you get for the defective car is often non-taxable, payments for lost income, emotional distress, or punitive damages might be taxed.

 

Should You Accept a Cash Settlement?

As mentioned above, you should approach cash settlements with caution. Manufacturers often push settlements because they cost them less, but these deals might leave you under-compensated. Consulting a lemon law attorney can help you get a better outcome. 

 

State vs. Federal Tax Implications

 

Federal Taxes

The IRS generally doesn’t tax compensatory damages for physical injuries or sickness. However, if your settlement includes punitive damages or interest, those amounts may be taxable. 

 

State Taxes 

California’s Franchise Tax Board tends to align with federal guidelines but may have its own regulations for certain aspects of lemon law settlements. For example, California doesn’t charge sales tax on replacement vehicles, but other parts of your settlement might be treated differently. 

 

Do You Need Help With a Lemon Law Claim? Contact Our Firm!

Do think you have a 2020 or newer Lemon car? Want to work with experts who know the ins and outs of California’s lemon law? At Norman Taylor & Associates, we’re here to help you understand your rights and get the best possible settlement. 

Keep in mind that we’re not tax attorneys, and you should always check with your Certified Public Accountant (CPA) for any tax-related issues. 

Call 818-244-3905 or contact us today for a FREE consultation, and let us guide you through the process! 

Schedule my consultation